S90v steel vs s30v. Low Alloy Steel Compositions.

S90v steel vs s30v 420HC offers better Toughness than S30V due to the decreased Rockwell hardness, it is thus less brittle than S30V steel. For edge retention over time, the S90V steel knives are clear winners here. Here is what S30V is made of: 1. 3. Once you get rid of the factory edge the steel performs much better. Dec 17, 2010 · thanks noctis for all the great info plus the patience to reply to such an involved question. Spy27 steel is known for its high hardness and wear resistance. 27 lbs. As you’d expect, cheaper steel isn’t as durable and long-lasting as a more expensive alternative, and that’s definitely true when you put the cheaper 420HC up against the premium S30v. If you're rough on a knife, S30V will be a better choice. May 24, 2019 · Benchmade's s30v is pretty good, although I generally prefer 20cv since I find it a little easier to sharpen. Everything is a balance of edge retention and toughness as well as stainless vs non- stainless. This steel is durable enough to withstand rigorous use without chipping or breaking. S30V has a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 59-61, renowned for a good balance between edge retention and toughness. S45VN leads in edge retention (580), followed by S30V (254) and S35VN (190). Final Thoughts . Rex45 is a better steel relative to S30V. Aug 11, 2023 · For the best steel, consider options like CPM-20CV, S35VN, S90V/S110V, ZDP-189, M4, and 3V. Low Alloy Steel Compositions. S90V is popularly known as a high-end, premium grade stainless steel, earning its reputation predominantly for unbeatable edge retention and wear resistance. But, for the practical knife user, I believe S30V is a better choice. Other questions What steel is better than S30V? S35V, CPM-154, and S45VN are all slightly better than S30V. Nov 28, 2024 · S30V Steel. Nov 17, 2015 · 420hc is a fine steel, S30v is "better". And they succeeded! Sep 26, 2021 · S30v Steel. S45VN has about the same or a little more toughness as S30V (both around 6 ft-lbs in some graphs, other graphs show S45VN toughness getting up to 7-8, still nothing to write home about) Jul 13, 2023 · M390 vs S90V – Complete Comparison Hardness. I prefer s45vn to s30v, but only because s45vn is significantly more stainless than s30v. Jun 8, 2020 · CPM-S30V/S35VN/S45VN - 7|5|6|5 - 341 TRC. S90V is a very durable, high wear resistance, and very corrosion resistant steel that makes it a great steel for almost all applications. S30V steel is a more popular name in the knife industry than M4. I would argue that S30V is better for every practical need. However, if you’re into knives then you will find the CPM S30V steel in a lot of premium EDC knives. The higher vanadium content of 9% in S90V versus 3% in S45VN leads to a higher volume fraction of hard vanadium carbides that resist abrasive wear, which gives S90V an advantage in edge retention. Given a choice between the 2 steels everything else being the same I would choose S90V. This company had already made great strides in developing high-quality steels, when they asked Chris Reeve why he wasn’t using any of their capable steels for his knife making. Two popular premium steels that have made their name on the market are S30V and Magnacut. S30V Steel Compared; 154cm vs. Advantages Of Using S90v Steel in Manufacturing A Knife. S30V has a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 59-61, making it a hard steel that can hold an edge for a long time. It was also somewhat finer than the previously available S60V and S90V. S30V steel finds its origins in the high-end market. Final thoughts on S90V vs 20CV Steel. 5% niobium. Sep 28, 2022 · Compare the characteristics, pros, cons, and performance of S30V and S90V steel knives. S35VN is tougher than both (really closer to a 6). 420hc is a great affordable steel but you need to touch them up often if you want a razor sharp blade. If you want a good all-around steel or a steel that is very tough you will want to go with M390. S90V is an exotic CPM steel. S35VN is a modification of S30V steel where the vanadium was reduced from 4 to 3% and replaced with 0. ) The marketing associated with each new steel that comes out makes it hard not to get jaded. Nov 18, 2024 · Toughness refers to a steel’s ability to resist chipping or cracking under stress. I have diamond stone and sharpening s90v feels no different to me than m390/20cv. Benchmade has 2 versions with different steel qualities. But they all have their own set of pros and cons. The BladeHQ one is kinda "meh" in my opinion (I don't agree with all their rankings, but with no hardness data, sure, maybe XHP does have edge retention equal to M390 and S90V), and the Benchmade one is laughable. However, M4 beats S90V in toughness and ease of sharpening, while S90V steel shines in corrosion resistance. Both steels are stainless steels known for their hardness, wear resistance, and edge retention. CPM-S30V and CPM-S45VN are two high-performance stainless steels used in knife making. Corrosion Resistance. The CATRA (Cutlery & Allied Trades Research Association) testing results show that S90V has 195% better edge retention relative to 440C stainless steel, while S30V achieves 145% relative to 440C. I'd personally go S30V (unless it's a custom from their website), just because it's their cheapest option but still an excellent steel. It has high carbon, vanadium and chromium in its composition which all contribute to its properties. S30V and CPM154 can keep semi-sharp for a long time. Know more with RangerExpert! Mar 26, 2024 · S90V steel achieves significantly higher edge retention compared to S30V steel. MagnaCut on the other hand is a new steel just being adopted, it is a bit more expensive than S30V but still cheaper than most premium blade steels in the market like M390 steel . Jan 10, 2024 · Blade steel is king when it comes to high-end knives. Each steel was tested with a knife that was produced just for the test, and then sharpened the same Sep 26, 2022 · Both S90V and M390 are considered premium steel. Let me break down some of its critical features. The 4 main elements in the CPM S30V steel are as follows: Carbon May 16, 2023 · M4 steel vs. Whether you use S90V steel for light or heavy-duty work, you won’t be disappointed. They are equal and score high for corrosion and wear resistance. This method ensures that the carbides, the hard particles that keep the blade sharp, are distributed evenly throughout the steel, resulting in a more homogeneous product. S30V Steel Qualities. 3% carbon. Spyderco offers this as the high-end steel for many of its evergreen blades, like the Paramilitary 2 , Paramilitary 3 Aug 28, 2011 · Between the two, I'd get the s110v. Oct 19, 2021 · Carbon Steel Compositions. S30V is a steel that is balanced very well between corrosion resistance, edge retention, wear resistance, and toughness. In conclusion, understanding the composition and properties of 154CM and S30V steel is crucial when choosing the right steel for a knife blade. Yes s30v might hold up better at a thinner angle. Edge Retention: S90V is nearly impossible to beat in terms of edge retention. S90V vs M390 steel May 16, 2020 · I recently picked up a brand new bench made altitude black in s90v. Crucible manufactures both S30V and S90V. That also depends on who you get the knife from, heat treament etc. M390, on the other hand, has an HRC of 60-62. Compared to After we went through the details about the S30V Steel, we finally arrived at our famous question, Is S30V good knife steel, I guess by now the answer is obvious “YES”, the steel offers high hardness, high wear resistance, high corrosion resistance, and a decent toughness, it’s considered a high-end Steel, and many users consider as a “SUPER STEEL”, And honestly I’m one of those Feb 1, 2009 · S125V vs. #edc #edcgear #tools #pocketknife #knife #steel #knifelife #americanmade #stainlesssteel #us Sep 10, 2023 · Today, I’d like to delve into the noteworthy world of blade materials and specifically focus on two popular materials, 154CM and S30V, which are widely acclaimed for their sturdiness, edge retention, and corrosion resistance characteristics. So if you are going to need a knife you will touch up once and last a long time, S90V is the better steel. Yet overall, it’s a tie between the 154cm and s30v. I use regularly a Buck Woodsman and a Buck folder (285 i think) in 420hc. 45% Chromium 14. S90V tends to be an all-around harder steel than S30V. But s30v isn't 440c by any means, it was at one time, a high end steel. Developed by Crucible Industries, both steels are popular choices due to their excellent balance of edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance. Both CPM S90V and CPM 20CV are exceptional quality super steel that offer similar performance in terms of grindability and edge retention. new guys are'nt generally aware of all the ups & downs of the atomic alloys. Rockewells are lower hardness S30v: This is a powdered steel intended for hard use appplications and (once sharp) will holf an edge for a long time. The improved performance is attributed to the increased chromium content and the addition of Nitrogen in its alloy. Second, S90V is harder to sharpen than S30V not because of hardness, but because of its composition. I am very very impressed with the steel, it holds a extremely good edge. Overall, CPM-S30V is the superior choice between the two for high-performance knives. 20CV steel, on the other hand, has excellent corrosion resistance, making it a great choice for kitchen knives and other applications where corrosion Jan 10, 2024 · CPM CruWear vs S30V Steel Hardness. Whichever steel your next knife uses will see you good for most tasks you come up against! With that said, let’s start by looking at how each metal performs as part of day-to-day use! Durability Jul 12, 2023 · S30V vs M390 – Complete Comparison Hardness. CPM 3V Steel vs. S30V. But if you need wear resistance, a staple won't destroy s110v, If you need something tougher and easier to sharpen, s30v will still keep an edge a Aug 2, 2022 · Blades made from this steel do not require regular sharpening; they offer the best edge retention in knife steels. S90V has a better edge retention but let's all be honest, edge retention for most of us is just numbers on a piece of paper. So given a choice, I'd go with CV20 every time. For example, S90V has a pretty shitty 3/10 in toughness and the summary says "This blade steel exhibits good toughness, but it does not meet the level of M390. Distinct Qualities of S30V Steel. Comparison Table: 154CM vs. and yes s110v might have much better wear resistance. . I find S30V to be a great balance and easy to sharpen and take care of. Sep 1, 2013 · I don't have anything in s110v but I have always found s30v to be a good all around steel. S45VN is more corrosion resistant than both (really a 7). May 26, 2023 · S30V and S90V are two steels that don’t disappoint in this aspect. S90v Steel VS S30v Steel Corrosion Resistance . Refined particles lead to more consistency throughout the steel which makes it harder to have soft spots in the steel. I don't currently have a Spyderco in either metal CRUCIBLE CPM® S30V® Issue #1 Carbon 1. It shares a number of similarities from the S90V since both are made using the same process and the idea behind them are the same. Aug 18, 2022 · S90V vs. However, they have differences that should be compared so you know which steel is better and why. also fowlers work with 52100 is classic. g. S30V and CPM-S30V are the same steel, but with different names. What are those reasons? And what are the differences between the two? My opinion of both s30v and S90v and which one comes out on top. S30V steel, a product of Crucible Industries, is enriched with vanadium. The best quality of S30V is that it is a very well-balanced steel. Nov 18, 2024 · Despite its higher hardness, S90V maintains comparable toughness to other premium powder metallurgy steels. They all bring really crucial benefits, and now we’re going to examine why these are so handy. Composition of High Speed Steels. His response led to the creation of S30v Feb 18, 2019 · This is the principle by which the 0. In terms of corrosion resistance, s90v steel and s30v steel are very similar, with s30v being slightly more resistant to corrosion than the former steel. If you're very careful with your knives, don't toss them in the sink or hammer them through hard beef bones, S90V will do very well. However, with proper heat treatment S90V and S35VN can reach up to 64 HRC. Oct 3, 2023 · Exploring S90V Steel. CPM S90V is a high-end martensitic stainless steel, known for its excellent wear resistance due to the addition of vanadium and carbon. Aug 14, 2021 · S90V Steel Vs M4. Like any steel, S90V has its downsides. Hardness, indicative of the steel’s resistance to wear and deformation, greatly influences the edge retention. In HRC, a lower number is indicative of a harder steel. Here is the short answer: CPM-S45VN has a slightly higher amount of chromium and niobium than S30V, which can improve its wear Aug 17, 2020 · Sales of steel to the knife industry took off much more for Crucible once S30V was introduced in 2001, giving the knife industry a steel they seemed to be much more interested in. " So they're pulling their punches and only saying something isn't as good compared to another steel, but won't outright say "this is bad". Jul 12, 2023 · Blade steel is a key consideration when choosing a knife. S90V takes more time and effort to sharpen to the same keeness and sharpness(duh). Real, good Italian and or American D2 is also really impressive, much better than the chinese stuff that Civivi,Kizer,A. In terms of price, knives made with M390 steel are more expensive than those made of S30V steel. S30V, also known as CPM-S30V, is a powder metallurgy steel. The S30V does fairly well in edge holding and stain resistance. As you'd expect the carbon content is very high but the secret here is the extreme quantities of vanadium, almost three times that found in Elmax or S30V. I welcome dialog, as long as it remains cordial, constructive and is conducted in a civilized manner. Fwiw, I have experienced similar behavior from s90v. The particular chemistry of CPM S30V leads to forming vanadium carbides, which are better at cutting and also harder than chromium carbides. M4 steel and S90Vsteel are produced using the same manufacturing process, which is the Particle Metallurgy process. Whilst there’s a noticeable difference in quality between the S30v and the 420HC, both will ultimately do a good job. to/2W4VeGqBenchamde Osborne Models :ht Dec 27, 2007 · The extreme edge retention steels (e. It‘s particularly notable for a very fine grain and great toughness. Jul 12, 2023 · Crucible Particle Metallurgy’s S30V (CPM S30V) and S90V (CPM S90V) are two popular knife steels. They wanted to make something that was simple to heat-treat, well-balanced to suit a wide range of applications, and better than everything else at the price point. However, S30V is high in carbon so it can be more prone to chipping than other steels. Dec 17, 2024 · S30V steel, on the other hand, is heat-treated to achieve a Rockwell hardness of 58-60. I cut up a lot of cardboard at work. Jul 13, 2023 · The steel can withstand considerable use and is less likely to chip or break compared to other high hardness steels. May 13, 2019 · Benchmade 940-1 :http://shrsl. The S90V is about $60 Jul 12, 2023 · S30V vs CPM154 – Complete Comparison Hardness. Many people will always want the super steel or the latest steels. They couldn’t be further apart. 15V blade steel is better than most knife steel, including S90V steel, 10V, and M398 steels. But how do they compare? In this article, we will look at each steel and see how they compare. However subtle differences in chemical composition lead to notable divergences in real-world cutting performance. (To be clear, S30V is just as great as ever as shown by these S30V steel knives. Sep 28, 2023 · S30V, produced by Crucible Industries in the United States, is also a powder-made stainless steel. my experience certainly supports your summations. S30V, properly called CPM S30V, is a hardened powder steel with a unique formulation that promotes the formation and uniform distribution of vanadium carbides which lend this formula its excellent hardness and abrasion resistance. For those not familiar with smelting steel, the various alloys in steel all have different specific gravities, meaning, they weigh more or less for a given volume. 5% Nb was added to steels K490 and S35VN, and to some extent in the larger niobium-addition steels. Mar 3, 2007 · What is the purpose of S45VN, cf S30V? S45VN’s card cut is around 520 compared to S30V which is in the 600 range, according to a Doc Thomas graphic. S90V held a surprisingly good edge, even the razor edge stayed, very uncharacteristic of of S__V steels in my First, the same steel can have different hardness depending on how it is heat treated. D2 Steel Compared; 154CM vs VG10 Steel Compared Mar 9, 2024 · The Basics: S30V. It is also known to be slightly softer than S30v steel, but it has a higher toughness. Apr 11, 2024 · Like S90V, it’s a high-hardness steel, but it’s more balanced than S90V. M390, CPM 20CV, or CTS-204p, for example. S30V and S45VN are two prominent blade steels that often get compared. M390 steel offers better toughness, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening. S90V steel has superior edge retention and is more resistant to wear and tear, making it a better choice for applications where durability is important. S90V is premium steel and is considered one of the best steel for the money. On the other hand, S30V is hard steel and delivers decent toughness. They offer great balance in toughness, wear resistance, edge retention, and corrosion resistance. M390. Aug 11, 2023 · 20CV vs S90V: Which one to choose? 20cv vs s90v? That depends entirely on your personal preference. Aug 11, 2023 · S90V vs S30V: CPM S30V provides better toughness and wear resistance but lags behind S90V in edge retention and grindability. My favorite at the moment is K390. But for a general EDC stainless steel, pretty much everything is going to be substantially worse than Magnacut in at least 2 out of the 3 primary steel qualities (edge retention, toughness, corrosion resistance). Jul 21, 2023 · CPM S90V Steel vs. S30V is a great all-around steel that works great for almost all knife tasks. Crucible went above and beyond to develop S30V to get a steel that could be heat treated with standard knifemaking equipment yet had balanced properties. May 18, 1999 · AS all you steel aficionados knows Vanadium carbide is small and very hard. Overview of nitro v and s30v steel. The hardness of a blade steel directly impacts its wear resistance and edge retention. The knife made with S90v remains sharp for a longer period of time. S30V, or CPM-S30V, is also developed by Crucible Industries. Sep 11, 2023 · Deep Dive into S30V Steel. When comparing VG10 vs S30v steel, both are good quality metals for an everyday carry knife. com/1lpszhttps://amzn. Jun 16, 2010 · I would say in practical use any good steel, be it s30v, s90v etc, will perform acceptably. Which steel is better, S30V or S90V? Both S30V and S90V are exceptional knife steels, but each has its own strengths. It can withstand rigorous use without chipping or breaking. Aug 11, 2023 · The steel even has the capability to outperform other top-quality steels like D2 and S30V. The addition of vanadium enhances its hardness and durability. It is crafted, or rather engineered, to offer a steadfast performance. Jan 31, 2022 · But this steel, which is a sequel to S35VN and a grandchild of S30V, is out in force. ” For the sake of edge retention and sharpness, S90V is superior to S30V and most other knife steels. CPM S90V: The impact toughness of S90V is around 19 ft-lbs at HRC 58[7]. S30V steel improved toughness is due to its balanced composition of primary elements like Carbon, Chromium, and vanadium (at least 4%), which gives it a more finely-grained microstructure. Oct 6, 2022 · S45VN steel is better than S30V steel. They are great but don't hold an edge like S30v or other "super" steels. Jun 17, 2014 · According to Sal Glesser this steel is closer to AUS-8 (AUS8) than American 440C, and is often compared to AUS-8 and 440B. M4 In my opinion S90V is a great steel but S30V is also. Corrosion Resistance: Both 420HC steel and S90V are stainless steel with good corrosion resistance. CPM S90V is a martensitic stainless steel known for exceptional wear resistance and corrosion resistance due to high levels of carbon and chromium. S90V has better edge retention, better blade durability, and better consistency, but S30V has better corrosion resistance and is easier to sharpen. No obvious differences, but factory edge last a bit longer with s90v ( but none of the S90V factory edge feels keen, unlike s30v) If you know how to sharpen, S30V takes less time to get sharp and keen, and can be run more acutely. CPM S90V vs S30V Also from the same manufacturer, the S30V is a premium-grade steel that is very popular among knife makers. Jan 22, 2011 · I believe I have narrowed down my next purchase, and I am just waffling on the blade steel. S90V is known for its durability, wear resistance, and edge integrity. However, S30V generally achieves slightly higher hardness than Cru-Wear. Aug 28, 2011 · But mainly, because Rex 45 is tougher than S30V, it can maintain a more acute edge which translates into better edge retention. Nitro V and S30v steel are two of the most popular steels used in knife making, and they both have their own particular advantages and disadvantages. Jul 13, 2023 · This is typically exemplified by blade edge retention. Wear resistance: S90V is a very wear resistant steel. Both M390 and S90V offer an equal level of edge retention. The superior edge retention capability of the S90V takes it to the top of its class. I can choose either HAP40 or S30V from Spyderco. S30V steel doesn’t hold an edge as great as S90V but is considerably easier to sharpen. Often considered to be a high end budget steel (an oxymoron if there ever was one). The improved fine-grained structure of S45VN stainless steel alloy provides better corrosion resistance and edge retention than S30V. Feb 2, 2014 · Back in 2005-2006 my “Super Steel” was CPM-S30V (regular great non-powdered steels were N690, 154CM and VG-10). Other Steels. With diamonds it sharpens as easily as S30V. Let’s start with a disclaimer. When it comes to repeated use, not many steels will hold up as well as S90V. What is everyone's experience with them. The polished edge that s90v takes is noticeable compared to m390. Crucible data sheet for S90V recommends an aim hardness of 56-59 HRC, while the data sheet for S35VN suggests an aim hardness of 58-61 HRC. S90V and S30V represent two tiers of stainless steel from the same Crucible Industries family. May 7, 2024 · S35VN vs S90V Steel Comparison Table Hardness. For ease of sharpening, the S30V wins. I would have to say my primary concern is edge retention. Not taking anything away from S30V, it's a very good steel, but CV20 holds a fine edge longer, I personally don't think it chips worse than S30V and I don't notice a difference in sharpening ease. 47 g/cm3) Thermal Conductivity Dec 3, 2023 · 3. S30V is a tough steel but not as tough as CPM M4. However, s110v is easier to share, although not compared to other types of steel. D2 and S30V are two popular blade steels often put head to head. G Russell, etc use. Nov 2, 2002 · S30V will be easier to sharpen in general, but S90V will hold an edge for longer while not being that much harder to sharpen. S35VN and S45VN are easier to sharpen S90V was designed to be very wear resistant, so it's really a tradeoff. S90V possesses a better capability of edge retention, wear resistance and hardness compared to S30V. The hardness of a steel directly impacts its wear resistance and edge retention. Steel Composition Mar 1, 2024 · Final Thoughts on S90V vs M390. When comparing CPM S90V steel to other popular knife steels, it’s essential to consider factors such as hardness, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance. S90V demands precise heat treatment protocols: Austenitizing temperature: 2100-2150°F (1150-1175°C) Dec 4, 2024 · Crucible's CPM S90V steel approaches the very pinnacle of wear resistance and edge retention. CPM-S90V is slightly better in almost all ways when compared to CPM-S30V. /in3 (7. 8Cr13MoV and S30V are pretty much on the opposite ends of the steel spectrum. a LMT barrel when you are shooting Guatemalan M193 through it. But, S30V beats S90V in terms of toughness and ease of sharpening. But in the past 5 years, there have been some amazing steels becoming more popular. Both of the steels are high ends but the differences lie in their origin. Jan 29, 2024 · For knives used in very tough tasks, lower alloy steels like 12C27 with inherently better toughness are typically preferred over either S90V or 20CV. The high vanadium content enables it to achieve the best abrasion resistance of any stainless blade steel. And the same applies to S90V if you use CBN and diamonds. Dec 31, 2022 · In terms of availability, both S30V and S35VN steel are fairly widely available, although S30V steel is more common due to its age, you will find most knives in S30V steel than S35VN steel. Each type of steel adds its Sep 30, 2023 · My collection includes blades from carbon steel to Damascus steel, CV, surgical steel, new high tech CPM steels, and a full alphabet and number soup of 420HC, S30V, S35, MagnaCut and probably others that I missed, and I'm pretty sure most of those are more than I really need or am able to optimize their use. S30V is a harder steel with an HRC of 56-58 which 154CM comes in around 58-61. Spy27 steel is more affordable than S30v steel, with a cost of around $2. Hardness is crucial in knife steel as it directly influences edge retention and wear resistance. Thread starter The_Guide; Start date Mar 31 high speed tool steel that is a great balance between toughness, and wear Apr 13, 2020 · The carbide structure of S30V was finer than the common 154CM (BG42 is similar) because of powder metallurgy. Its release in the early 2000s was warmly welcomed by knifemakers. Sep 26, 2021 · The result was wear-resistant steel that was able to retain machinability. This is considered moderate for a high-carbide steel but lower than many other knife steels due to the large volume of vanadium carbides. Although I'd say for typical edc use I don't find a huge difference between the two. stainless thread? The difference between CPM154/S30V and 52100/1095? The carbon steels rust! They tend to be harder so they keep the initial sharp edge longer than the CPM stainless, but they just wear duller and duller. Testing shows: S90V: 5-6 ft-lbs in unnotched Charpy tests; S30V: 6-7 ft-lbs under similar conditions[3][4] Heat Treatment Requirements. It can withstand heavy use but might chip under severe conditions. , S90V/S110V/S125V, ZDP-189) still have a niche they dominate. S35VN vs S30V S30V is a great all-around steel; you can’t go wrong with S30V. The only few blade steel offering better edge retention than CPM 15V blade steels are Maxamet and Rex 121 steel. It’s a real dilemma to choose the best when thinking about S90v vs 20cv. S30v steel, on the other hand, is harder than Spy27 steel, yet it is still considered a relatively tough steel. 00 per inch. Oct 7, 2023 · The stainless properties of s90v and s30v are roughly the same, but the s90v holds a working edge noticeably longer. With a Rockwell hardness scale rating of 58 – 61, both steels are so close in hardness that depending on the heat treatment of the steel they could be called equivalent. Short Answer: Comparing S30V to CPM-20CV S30V is a more well-rounded steel that is good S90V and M390 are two steels that both have different purposes and are best used for different tasks. Below shows the results of CATRA experiments reported by others that I have shown in other articles. Slightly more stain resistant than S30V too. Oct 9, 2022 · Comparing S90V With Other Knife Steel Options: S90V vs. S30V knives are more popular than M390 knives because of the great balance of toughness, edge retention, corrosion resistance, and affordable price. S30V Downsides: S90V is also an expensive steel. sniper blades is one of those. The downside is the increased brittleness that may accompany such hardness. to/2YpI4RWKnives With CPM S90V :http://shrsl. Edge retention between s30v and s45vn seems similar, but I've had s30v rust in my pocket while s45vn has proven to be m390-level stainless. S90V is an ultra-high-carbon steel, containing 2. Week before I got an S90V ZT 0095 but didn't get around to fixing the edge up until last week. During my time with S30V blades, I enjoyed their admirable edge retention, which although less than Elmax, was significant. Both of these steels have their reputation for being reliable, strong, holding an edge, and corrosion resistant. May 21, 2022 · The s30v in fact, is better in terms of edge retention but that’s traded off with difficult sharpening as compared to the 154cm. Jan 30, 2023 · Other substances which are added to improve the toughness, strength, and hardness of the S90v steel are 0. S30v is stainless steel that was created by American-based Crucible Industries in 2001, with knife blades in mind. S90V is S30V if it hit the gym. You can read about my CATRA edge retention testing in this article. But I like the variety. With the short answer out of the way, we can take a deeper dive into each steel and see which one is better at what. I re-profiled Rex45 without much effort. S60V. I wouldn't consider damascus a hard repetitve use steel for something like carboard boxes. CPM S30V is a martensitic stainless steel, known for its excellent edge retention, corrosion resistance and strength. Both offer good hardness, toughness, and corrosion resistance, but they differ in wear resistance and ease of sharpening. (Mind you, it turns dark faster. 7Cr17MoV is an affordable stainless steel that offers moderate hardness and edge retention. Mar 19, 2010 · The difference between S30V and S90V for most people is like agonizing over a Noveske barrel vs. M390 exhibits a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 60-62, striking a balance between hardness and toughness, with an excellent wear resistance. [1] Pinnow, Kenneth E. Apr 1, 2011 · I have a fair bit of experience with both S30V and CV20/M390, and IMO there is no contest; I prefer CV20. 00% Vanadium 4. Damascus and S90V are both a lot better than S30V, but are a lot more expensive Sep 1, 2009 · Is this a powder metallurgy vs. Those sort of steel ranking charts without any actual measured data points should always be taken with a grain of salt. 154CM. The composition of S30V enables it to have better toughness and corrosion resistance than S90V. Sep 29, 2022 · 420HC vs S30V Toughness. It also contains 9% vanadium, which is As we have discussed, s90v is not easy to sharpen. This leads S30v to have a relatively good grindability so that it can be sharpened and honed with less tool wear and expense. Dec 6, 2020 · Unless you really like the color of the handles the S30V one comes with (seems to be either pink or green zome, from what google image search tells me), I'd look for something better than S30V. How good is the S30V steel at holding an edge? Ans. S30V offers excellent all-around performance with good edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance. 40% Tungsten, and 0. It has good edge retention, good toughness, good wear resistance, and is pretty Feb 1, 2023 · Also Read: S30v Vs S35vn: Differences & Similarities Does S90v Stainless Steel Good For A Knife? S90v or CPM S90v was initially known as CPM-420 and was released in 1995. S30V is a very well-rounded premium steel. Having used both M390 and S90V extensively, I can certainly attest to the impressive edge retention and wear resistance of S90V steel. “Corrosion resistant, high vanadium, powder metallurgy tool steel articles with improved metal to metal wear resistance and a method for producing the Jul 12, 2023 · Knife steel is a vital aspect to consider when selecting a blade. Jan 15, 2024 · MagnaCut knives tend to be more expensive than S30V knives, this is because S30V steel has been widely adopted over the years and is regarded as a budget steel. CPM-S30V, on the other hand, is a premium stainless steel that offers exceptional edge retention, hardness, and corrosion resistance. If you want a steel that is great for slicing, then you will want to go with S90V. Because S90V holds its edge so well, it can be hard to work with and sharpen. May 28, 2023 · The main difference between S30V and S35VN steel is their toughness. S35VN steel is considered to be tougher and is, therefore, better suited for larger knives such as hunting, tactical, and survival knives. But, keep in mind that both these steels are brittle, which is why you might want to consider other options if you are looking for tougher knives. Feb 29, 2024 · In comparison, S90V steel offers about 40% better edge retention than S45VN steel. Mar 6, 2023 · In partnership with Crucible Industries, a steel producer based in New York, Chris Reeve developed the S35VN and S30V steels using a specialized technique known as Crucible Particle Metal (CPM) technology. CPM-440V was rebranded to CPM-S60V some time around the year 2000 [8], and CPM-420V was renamed to CPM-S90V. S35vn Compared; 154cm Steel vs. Harder steel (as measured in the Rockwell C scale in HRC) maintains an edge longer but is harder to sharpen. In-Depth Comparison of Magnacut and S90V. S30v is good, but I prefer the higher wear resistant steels. However, S30V is a step down from M4 as it has inferior edge retention and toughness. That was your complete guide to s30v vs. Spyderco updated many evergreen models to run S45VN as a base steel, and the results are great. refer to the steel as S30V and others as CPM-S30V, but it’s the same thing. Stainless Steel Compositions. How about s110v? How does it stack up on edge retention, toughness, strength, edge stability etc? S110V has good edge retention, but S90V is a better all-purpose steel. Jan 9, 2023 · Both 20CV and S30V steel offer average toughness and are not the best, however, S30V has slightly better toughness than 20CV steel. Short Answer: S30V FAQs about s30v vs s90v steel What is the primary difference between a s30v and s90v steel? The primary difference between s30v and s90v steel is that s30v is softer and easier to sharpen, while s90v is harder and more difficult to sharpen. S90V vs. Both are highly durable steels that can take a beating. S90V is a higher price steel but it is a higher quality steel. , William Stasko, and John Hauser. It’s often measured using Charpy impact tests. S30V vs S90V . However, 420HC has better corrosion resistance than S90V, which has lower chromium content. In this article, we will compare D2 and S30V in terms of their composition, hardness, toughness, corrosion resistance, edge retention, and ease of sharpening to conclude which one is superior for knives. Now we can take a closer look at each steel, when you would want one steel over the other, and what the best tasks are for each steel. So it is no surprise that it holds an edge better than Magnacut. CPM S30V and CPM Cru-Wear are both air-hardening tool steels that can achieve high Rockwell hardness levels, making them suitable for wear-resistant applications like knives, cutting tools and dies. Soft steels like 420HC tend to offer great toughness. Dec 14, 2017 · Learnes I'm absolutely in love with M390, and just last week got a knife in S110V (Paramilitary 3). Additionally, S90V is a specialty steel that is best for applications needing maximum edge retention. May 13, 2022 · There’s a reason that S30V is such a popular steel for making knife blades with, and that’s because of this great range of chemical ingredients. Edge Retention. One thing against S90V is it tilts toward M4, meaning that it seems to tarnish a slight bit more than M390. S90v is made using the Particle Metallurgy process. CPM S90V. 5% Silicon and Manganese, 0. Some companies, groups, people, etc. It sharpens easier and is cheaper while still having a pretty great edge retention. To assist you in choosing the best steel for your cutting needs, this detailed article will examine the distinctions between these two alloys. Oct 2, 2023 · CPM-S30V. They offer the same level of high edge retention. s90v steel knives. As we’ve suggested, S30V is great at resistance to getting old and broken down. S90V is distinguished by its exceptional edge retention and wear resistance, surpassing S30V in these aspects due to its higher vanadium content. Composition of High Alloy Tool Steels. Compared to Elmax, it has lower carbon, resulting in relatively less rigidity but easier sharpening. 420HC knives will withstand high-impact applications compared to 420HC Knives. In this article, we will be contrasting S30V and S45VN based on their composition, hardness, toughness, corrosion resistance, edge retention, and sharpening ease to establish which one is superior for knife-making. CPM S30V Steel Chemical Composition. In-Depth Comparison. Over the years, I’ve found that S90V retains its sharp edge for an impressively long time. The 4% vanadium content helps with wear resistance and edge holding. If I had to pick one knife steel to use for the rest of my life, it probably would be S30V. Yet, there are reasons you may actually want to choose 8Cr13MoV over S30V. Is S90V Good Steel For Knives? May 10, 2022 · S90V vs S30V steel. In terms of performance, S90V steel is often considered to be a better choice than 20CV. 00% CPM S30V D2 440C 154 CM CPM CPM CPM CPM 3V S90V 9V 10V CPM Steel Conventional Steel Elastic Modulus 32 X 106 psi (221 GPa) Density 0. The smaller vanadium and niobium carbides in MagnaCut allow it to be sharpened effectively even with aluminum oxide stones, while S90V requires diamond or CBN due to its larger vanadium carbides. in addition some makers can tweak the simpler alloys to very high rockwells w/o brittleness. Now, CPM S30V is a different story. S30V was developed in 2001 by steelmaker Crucible Industries in coordination with leading knifemakers specifically for use in high-end pocket knives. S90V could be called a super steel (at least thats what I call it) while S30V is a great steel and better for ease of sharpening, you will however have to sharpen it more and it wont take as good of an edge as S90V. S90V’s full name is CPM-S90V, and the CPM stands for Crucible Particle Metallurgy, which is a process the steel goes through in order to refine the steel’s particles. 45% carbon; 14% chromium; 2% molybdenum Contrasting Capabilities – S90V versus S30V steel. S110V vs. May 19, 2003 · S30V's big advantage comes from particle metallurgy, which allows the steel maker to keep the alloys homogenously distributed and keep the impurities out. Highest edge retention of the three, at the cost of being less tough, and less stain resistant (still very resistant). 03% of Phosphorus. Sep 28, 2020 · S125V has the highest edge retention of any available stainless steel though it gives up toughness and workability vs S90V to get it. Jul 13, 2023 · CPM CRUWEAR vs S30V – Complete Comparison Hardness. Edge Retention Feb 28, 2024 · Crucible states that S90V steel due to its high vanadium carbide content, will be slightly more difficult than that of D2 steel and MagnaCut Steel. I'd likely choose S30V for larger knives, because they're subjected to greater S30V and CPM-20CV are two steels that are considered to be among the best and most well-rounded of all the steels out there. Edge Retention: CPM-S90V offers far superior edge retention compared to S45VN. S30V steel, on the other hand, is more suitable for smaller pocket knives that will be subjected to less heavy use. Basically… Aug 13, 2005 · Damascus: buttery smooth and easy to sharpen takes a great edge but really needs to be fine tuned a lot. S90V. Though the margin of difference between the two is not that great it is noticable. Still, it's a very decent steel, offering a good balance between edge retention and ease of sharpening. Oct 15, 2023 · S90V is a premium steel that retains its sharpness for longer, making it ideal for people who require razor-sharp knives for their work. This makes it a harder steel that delivers superior edge retention and wear resistance. While there is no shortage of steel selections for knife fans and pros, two high-performance stainless steel giants are S35VN and S30V. The comparison between S90V and S30V steel involves two high-end stainless steels designed for the most demanding knife users. 3V is by far my absolute favorite steel, its just so tough, and it always seems to hold an edge nearly as good as S30V/S35VN. CPM CRUWEAR has a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 63-65, ensuring impressive wear resistance and edge retention. Nov 7, 2017 · Today, S30V is sometimes considered an ancient steel while newer steels like S110V are praised for being even better. As for the tougher steel, S30V takes the lead, but only to the slightest degree. Note that some tests show similar edge retention between the 3, close to ELMAX. S30V vs CPM-S30V–is there a difference? Unlike D2 and CPM-D2, there isn’t a difference between S30V and CPM-S30V. S45VN knives offer better performance than S30V knives. Feb 25, 2024 · S90V Steel vs S30V. Corrosion resistance is the only part where S30V stands above M4. S90v is a tough steel blade. It can hold good edge for a significant amount of time. 00% Molybdenum 2. Jul 13, 2023 · Read More: S35VN Knife Steel Review. S30V and S35VN knives are generally considered to be similar in price, with slight variations depending on the knife design and the current market conditions. non thread, or a carbon vs. Related Posts. I found wear resistance of S90V seems to have slight upper hand, even it is a little bit softer than M390 within Benchmade HT. com/1lpswhttps://amzn. I am new to knives and am looking at the benchmade hidden canyon hunter. I reckon any of the SV steels would be up to the task of breaking down any animal, and perform well. Jan 4, 2023 · S30v and s90v are both highly durable stainless steel knives. The key takeaway is that S90V offers substantially better edge retention and wear resistance due to its higher hardness and vanadium carbide content. This steel is used by custom makers and high-end production knives and is considered one of the superior steels for any cutting tool. Even with powder metallurgy, carbides can form in a range of sizes. 8Cr13MoV is a budget steel and S30V is a premium steel. Find a knife that you like (handle it first if possible), and go with it. Many call it a “super steel. Nitro V is a high-carbon steel that is extremely hard and has excellent edge retention. However, for my preferences, I generally favor M390 over S90V. S30V steel’s toughness is measured at around six ft-lbs, whereas S90V rates five ft-lbs. S30V has less carbon and vanadium than S90V, with the same amount of chromium but more molybdenum. Apr 13, 2024 · VG10 vs S30v – Usability. The corrosion resistance of a steel determines its ability to resist rust and oxidation. If I had one complaint it would be that I experience some occasional (very minor) microchipping in the edge. Learn how to choose between them based on edge retention, toughness, ease of sharpening, and intention of use. ---dennis S90v has the reputation of being chippy but in my experience Benchmade heat treats their s90v👌. Jun 6, 2023 · A brief summary of S30V steel. Aug 17, 2024 · S30v vs 420HC – Usability Summary. CATRA testing has shown that S30v has an impressive ability to hold its edge, in relation to other similarly formulated knife steels. I would suggest the s90v because it has better edge retention Jul 5, 2023 · S30V vs. Oct 24, 2023 · Check out all the S30V Steel Knives on Sale at Amazon. mdyqt jdzrf ebfm ymom mcwax ymueykx upc janfm vtzso ujx